The Disadvantages of Pipe-type Lightning Arresters

The Disadvantages of Pipe-type Lightning Arresters

1. The pipe is prone to moisture, which may cause surface flashover at the working voltage, leading to the false operation of the lightning arrester. The solution is to connect an air gap called an external gap in series during use.

2. The lower limit of arc extinction current is related to the tightness of the arc contact with the tube wall. After the lightning arrester is operated multiple times, the material vaporizes, the inner diameter increases, the tube wall becomes thinner, and it cannot reach the breaking value specified on the nameplate. When the inner diameter increases to 120% – 125% of the original, it cannot be used anymore.

3. The arc-extinguishing ability is related to the size of the power frequency continuation current. When the continuation current is too large, too much gas is produced, and the gas pressure inside the tube becomes too high, causing the tube to burst; when the continuation current is too small, too little gas is produced, and the gas pressure inside the tube is too low, which is insufficient to extinguish the arc. Therefore, the ability of the pipe-type lightning arrester to extinguish the arc with the continuation current has certain range limitations.

4. The pipe-type lightning arrester has an external gap, which is greatly affected by the environment. Thus, like the protection gap, it has the disadvantages of a steeper characteristic curve and large discharge dispersion. It is not easy to achieve reasonable insulation coordination with the protected equipment.

5. After the pipe-type lightning arrester operates, it generates a cutoff wave, which endangers the insulation of equipment with coils, such as transformers.

6. To eliminate overvoltage caused by oscillation, a resistor is connected in series in the discharge circuit of the lightning arrester. The larger the resistor, the less likely it is to oscillate. However, when the lightning current passes through the resistor and the gap, a very high residual voltage is generated. If the residual voltage is greater than the insulation strength of the protected equipment, the equipment will be broken and damaged.